Local Opinion: Constitutional Court Postpones ‘Lex CEU’ & ‘NGO’ Bills

  • 7 Jun 2018 8:44 AM
  • BudaPost
Local Opinion: Constitutional Court Postpones ‘Lex CEU’ & ‘NGO’ Bills
A liberal and a pro-government pundit lambast the Constitutional Court for not discussing the constitutionality of the so-called ‘lex CEU’ and the anti-NGO legislation.

On Tuesday, the Constitutional Court announced that it will postpone discussion of the two controversial pieces of legislation, passed by Parliament a year ago, until the European Court decides whether the two laws are in-line with EU law.

One set new conditions on the operations of the partly Soros-funded Central European University, while the other obliged foreign funded NGOs to mention this fact in their publications.

On Index, Gábor Miklósi wonders if the Constitutional Court even began to inspect the lex CEU and the NGO laws, or just pretended to do so, in order to save face. The liberal columnist finds it a ‘spectacular stunt’ that the same Constitutional Court which in the dispute over mandatory migrant redistribution quotas in the EU, claimed that the Hungarian Constitution should put ahead of EU law, is now willing to compromise Hungary’s legislative autonomy.

Miklósi suspects that the Constitutional Court does not have the guts to decide in the ‘politically extremely sensitive’ debate over the CEU and NGOs. Meanwhile, a new NGO bill, unofficially called “Stop Soros” is under consideration in Parliament.

Magyar Idők’s Dávid Megyeri is also appalled by the Constitutional Court’s decision to postpone the verdict on the lex CEU and the NGO bill. The pro-government commentator thinks that the Constitutional Court has practically limited its own sovereignty by suggesting that it is subordinated to the EU court.

Megyeri agrees with the dissenting judges that the Constitutional Court has created a precedent for the EU court to intervene in Hungarian legal affairs. Megyeri interprets all this as ‘putting Hungarians at the mercy of the unlawful EU institutions’.

In conclusion, Megyeri suspects that the Luxembourg court will rule against the lex EU and the NGO bills, but Megyeri nonetheless thinks that the two laws are ‘resilient enough to withstand the challenge of liberal globalist critics, and will prove lawful even without the Constitutional Court’s decision’.

MTI Photo

This opinion does not necessarily represent the views of XpatLoop.com or the publisher. Your opinions are welcome too - for editorial review before possible publication online. Click here to Share Your Story

 

  • How does this content make you feel?

XpatLoop Media Partner

BudaPost

Launched in May 2011 to provide a balanced picture of matters covered in Hungary’s national press. Their aim is to make it easier for English-speakers to understand where this country is now and where it’s heading according to the full spectrum of media opinions.

Explore More Reports

  • Local Opinion: ’Stop Soros’ Bill Passed By Parliament

    Local Opinion: ’Stop Soros’ Bill Passed By Parliament

    • 22 Jun 2018 11:40 AM

    A leftist analyst writes that the government side borrowed the ‘Stop Soros’ campaign from their Macedonian allies, while pro-government commentators believe that it expresses the will of the Hungarian people.

  • Local Opinion: Dispute Over Constitutional Amendments

    Local Opinion: Dispute Over Constitutional Amendments

    • 20 Jun 2018 6:57 AM

    A Marxist philosopher excoriates the government’s proposed constitutional amendments and accuses the government of ethnic nationalist politics as well as the uprooting of the rule of law. A conservative lawyer, on the other hand, thinks that the defence of Hungary’s ethnic composition and constitutional identity is necessary to strengthen democracy

  • Local Opinion: Anniversary Of Soviet Withdrawal From Hungary

    Local Opinion: Anniversary Of Soviet Withdrawal From Hungary

    • 20 Jun 2018 6:43 AM

    A legal expert who took part in the negotiations on the withdrawal of Soviet armed forces from Hungary recounts hitherto unknown details of the talks and complains that the general public is unaware of the importance of the date when Hungary regained her independence.

  • Local Opinion: Fidesz To Ban Living In Public Space

    Local Opinion: Fidesz To Ban Living In Public Space

    • 15 Jun 2018 9:55 AM

    As Fidesz MPs ask the government to introduce a constitutional ban on sleeping rough regularly and living on the streets in general, a left-wing Christian pundit finds the proposal inhumane, while a pro-government columnist welcomes it.