Video Opinion: Hungary Ends Legal Recognition Of Transsexual Citizens

  • 28 May 2020 8:07 AM
  • BudaPost
Video Opinion: Hungary Ends Legal Recognition Of Transsexual Citizens
The new law stipulating that sex at birth cannot be changed in legal documents has ignited a debate between two sides which speak mutually exclusive languages.

An omnibus bill introducing, among others, the concept of ‘sex at birth’ rather than ‘sex’, was passed by the dominant Fidesz majority in Parliament on Tuesday.

The difference is that sex at birth, by definition, cannot be changed except in extreme cases where it is proven to be biologically mistaken. So far, ‘transitions’ from one gender to another, have been tolerated by the authorities and birth certificates could be changed accordingly.

This was possible despite the absence of explicit legislation which recognised the possibility of a transition from one sex to another. Over the past three years such procedures have been halted by the government.

The new law puts an end to the ambiguity which transsexual people had found acceptable, although not satisfactory. There is no official record of the number of officially recognized gender transitions, but experts believe it must be in the hundreds.

On Wmn.hu a progressive lifestyle web magazine, Noé Horváth, a man who was a female called Noémi at birth, believes thousands of transgender people will now be left with no choice but emigration.

He estimates that there might be as many as 50 thousand transgender people in Hungary.

The new legislation, he suggests, will cause huge difficulties in their everyday lives, unless they have already had their transition officially recognised – those people, he explains, will find themselves in impossible situations facing even the most banal ID checks, e.g. when crossing borders, using their credit cards or applying for jobs.

On Mandiner, constitutional lawyer and university lecturer Zsolt Szabó agrees with the new legislation.

To substantiate his position, he recalls the example of a 69-year-old Dutchman who applied for a new birth certificate proposing a much later birth date, as he felt much younger than his official age.

His request was of course rejected, but if sexual transitions can be recorded retroactively in birth certificates, Szabó asks, then why not allow people to change their birth dates as well?

This opinion does not necessarily represent the views of XpatLoop.com or the publisher. Your opinions are welcome too - for editorial review before possible publication online. 
Click here to Share Your Story 

  • How does this content make you feel?

XpatLoop Media Partner

BudaPost

Launched in May 2011 to provide a balanced picture of matters covered in Hungary’s national press. Their aim is to make it easier for English-speakers to understand where this country is now and where it’s heading according to the full spectrum of media opinions.

Explore More Reports

  • Hungarian Opinion: Mass Debate Over Transgender Sex Change Surgery

    Hungarian Opinion: Mass Debate Over Transgender Sex Change Surgery

    • 12 May 2020 8:22 AM

    A left-wing liberal commentator accuses the government of violating the rights of transgender individuals by proposing restrictions on changing one’s biological gender in official documents. A pro-government columnist thinks that the opposition is spreading conspiracy theories to weaken the government.

  • 24th Budapest Pride Festival: Joint Press Release By Major Embassies

    24th Budapest Pride Festival: Joint Press Release By Major Embassies

    • 2 Jul 2019 11:04 AM

    The following joint press release is issued by the Embassies of Argentina, Australia, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Cyprus, Denmark, Ecuador, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Mexico, Montenegro,  The Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, Serbia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, The United Kingdom, The United States, and the British Council.

  • Local Opinion: Dispute Over Gender Studies

    Local Opinion: Dispute Over Gender Studies

    • 13 Aug 2018 8:10 AM

    As the government proposes to cancel the accreditation of gender studies university degree programs, left-wing and liberal pundits accuse the government of ideology driven interference in higher education. Conservative commentators are divided on the proposed ban.