Hungary’s Top Court Rejects Complaint Against Kúria Ruling On Internet Comments

  • 29 May 2014 9:00 AM
Hungary’s Top Court Rejects Complaint Against Kúria Ruling On Internet Comments
The Constitutional Court on Wednesday threw out a complaint filed by the Association of Hungarian Content Providers against a ruling by Hungary’s supreme court, the Kúria, concerning derogatory comments made on the internet. The Kúria had earlier ruled against the association, saying that commenters on a website under the association’s control had “overstepped the boundaries of free expression” and that the website allowed for “seriously derogatory, humiliating” remarks.

 In its decision, the Constitutional Court said that the internet was not an area outside the law and internet communication was also governed by relevant legal stipulations. Fundamental rights and obligations, as outlined in the constitution, must also be observed in internet communication, it said.

The operator of a website is responsible for blog entries or comments, even if those comments are moderated, the top court said. The Civil Liberties Union (TASZ) said, however, that the ruling would seriously impact Hungary’s internet practices and could “significantly restrict political discussions”.

Unconditional responsibility, as suggested by the ruling, will make it “extremely risky” for content providers to allow for any comments at all, TASZ said. “No matter if providers moderate comments or not, even if they remove harmful content, they will still be held responsible,” it said. TASZ insisted that content providers should only be penalised if they do not remove the objected content after it is brought to their attention.

Source www.hungarymatters.hu

Follow that link to sign-up for MTI’s twice-daily newsletter.

  • How does this content make you feel?